On one hand, this is a happy day for Harry Potter fans, as Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them is finally in theaters. On the other hand, two people in the Potter realm could really use some Felix Felicis right about now.

Evanna Lynch, best known for playing the eccentric Luna Lovegood in the last four Harry Potter films, and Robbie Jarvis, a.k.a. Young James Potter in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, have called it quits.

The couple confirmed they were dating in April 2015, and just last month, Jarvis shared a sweet #TBT pic of the couple in New Zealand, “pretending to be Hobbits on the farm where they shot ‘The Shire’ scenes in LOTR.” But when Lynch was asked at the Fantastic Beasts premiere November 10 if she and Jarvis were still together, she admitted, “No, but we’re still friends.” Well, I guess that’s better than being enemies, right?

H/T Refinery 29