For some "Are You the One?" daters, looking for love in Puerto Rico was a dream come true. But when the game ended and the 21 contestants were thrust back into reality, what happened?

On tonight's reunion show, the second crop of "AYTO" cast members sat down with Ryan Devlin to reveal the whos, whats and wheres of post-finale life, and though some things made perfect sense (Ellie still thinks Anthony's flawless, Ashley's still very much a virgin), there were some curve balls that would have struck out Teddy Ballgame. Look back at tonight's most shocking "Are You the One?" reunion revelations below, and tell us which left you gobsmacked!

Jenni went to Chicago...but it wasn't to see John.

The bubbly blonde had some trouble nailing down her perfect match (Layton? Anthony?) early on, but seemed to figure everything out once she and John had an honest conversation. Welp, that all changed once the grand prize had been won, as Jenni found her feelings for Anthony had manifested once more, and she even visited him in Chicago while completely ignoring the fact that John was also a Windy City resident.

Pratt hung Paris out to dry.

After clearing up the "tiny penis" remark -- which she insists was taken out of context -- Paris explained that as soon as the show ended, Pratt gave her the cold shoulder, stopped responding to her texts and never said sorry for icing her out. "He didn't try to see me, he's never apologized -- he still can't apologize to my face," Paris said. "I really did fall in love...this sh**'s real." Thankfully, Pratt agreed he had some growing up to do. "I know I f**ed up, I'm still in love with her," he said. "I'm heartbroken...deep down, I feel like she's the girl I want to spend the rest of my life with."

Bri broke things off with Curtis.

The Truth Booth denied them as a Perfect Match...and maybe it was right. While on the show, nothing short of a hurricane could have kept Bri and Curtis apart, but when the game ended, Bri said the relationship's progression into real life was too much too soon, and that she just couldn't handle it.

Dario had sex with Shelby...

...and his perfect match, Ashley, was right next to them. "My feelings were hurt," Ashley said at the reunion, after Dario admitted to hooking up with his initial crush only moments after winning the big money. "When that...happens, you feel disrespected...but I'm just a bigger person and I'm choosing not to dwell on it. It's not like me and Dario were gonna hook up."

Alex was Brandon and Christina's "other woman."

Brandon only had eyes for Christina on "Are You the One?", but once the cameras went down, he saw another lady in a new light. After the final episode, Christina made the bold choice to move to Las Vegas to be with Brandon, but just when her bags were all packed, she discovered that he'd slept with Alex, and her tearful recounting of finding out pulled at our heartstrings. "[I had] quit my job, I sold my car," Christina said. "I did everything. We had the plane ticket ready for me to go...I'm hurt by what he did."