Evan Peters is synonymous with American Horror Story, but he hasn't shown up on Roanoke yet — causing fans to lose their minds, then put on their tinfoil hats to come up with theories right and left.

So while you're waiting for Peters to grace us with his presence on Roanoke, see if you can remember which of his characters from past seasons said which quote. Hope you know your Tate Langdon-isms from your James March ones.