Co-host Kamie Crawford returns to help uncover the truth about Manthan's decade-long love Leah, whose headline-making trouble with the law is just the start of her secrets.aired 6/12/19
Nev teams up with NFL star Rashad Jennings to get to the bottom of Deven's online relationship with James by surprising him in Catfish's first-ever trap of its kind.aired 1/23/19
Grammy-nominated artist Elle King joins Nev to dig deep and uncover the truth about Nique and her Tumblr love, who met as characters in a role-playing forum.aired 1/16/19
Nev and co-host Slick Woods help Aubri get answers about Brian, who only communicates through Snapchat even though they attend the same college.aired 1/09/19
After Mathan travels to Seattle only to be stood up by Leah, he sends her one final text message to close the book on their decade-long relationship.6/12/19
Kamie Crawford teams up with Nev to help Mathan declare his love for his best friend Leah, a girl he claims he has been in contact with for almost a decade.6/11/19
Nev revisits Selita's first time standing in as co-host during an episode in which she helps Bianca learn the truth about Brogan.
Nev seemingly encounters the supernatural for the first time when Courtney claims to be in contact with Kayla's deceased father.6/03/19