Outspoken Lawmakers Listen To Cash, The Boss, Sinatra To Unwind
Sen. Joseph Lieberman listens to pop crooner Frank Sinatra's music and
was a casual "Seinfeld" watcher.
Rep. Dick Armey, the House majority leader, enjoys John Wayne's westerns
and listens to the country music of Johnny Cash -- the same Johnny Cash
who counts among his most famous lyrics, "I shot a man in Reno just to
watch him die."
Sen. John McCain considers the 1952 Marlon Brando/Anthony Quinn war
movie "Viva Zapata!" his favorite film of all time. Rep. Henry Hyde
listens to Beethoven and Mozart in his office and loves the World War II
movie "Saving Private Ryan."
Those are among the key politicians who have been debating the role that
violence in music, movies and other media plays in child development and
behavior since the April 20 killings at Columbine High School in
Littleton, Colo., by two students. But even those who would amend the
laws governing distribution of entertainment need their diversions as
the day's arguments end and they return home for a night of relaxation.
Judging from the responses of their press secretaries, the legislators'
tastes in music and movies tend to be mild and to ring of patriotism
(see list). And their choices occasionally contain
the very violence they have condemned.
Lieberman, 57, enjoys such Sinatra tunes as "I Got You Under My Skin"
excerpt) and generally confines his television viewing to sports
and news programs on cable, according to his press secretary, Dan
Gerstein. But Gerstein pointed out that Lieberman tries to view and
listen to as much of what is being produced by the entertainment industry
as he can.
"He is not pop cultural illiterate," Gerstein said. "If he's going to
criticize something, he at least watches it."
Sinatra, coincidentally, called rock 'n' roll artists "cretinous goons"
during a 1958 congressional hearing and was rumored to have links to
organized crime through much of his career.
Lieberman, D-Conn., and McCain, R-Ariz., last week introduced legislation
in the U.S. Senate that would force the entertainment industries to,
within six months, create a uniform parental-warning label for all movies,
videos, video games and music.
McCain, 62, listens to '50s and '60s rock, according to a member of his
staff who wouldn't name particular artists. One of his idols is actor
Jimmy Stewart, who often portrayed war heroes in his films. McCain was
taken prisoner while fighting in the Vietnam War.
In the House of Representatives, Reps. Bart Stupak, D-Mich., and Zack
Wamp, R-Tenn., proposed an amendment to a juvenile-crime bill that would
match the McCain-Lieberman proposal which failed last week. Dick Kopper,
the 41-year-old Wamp's press secretary, said the two will reintroduce
their labeling bill as a freestanding piece of legislation by next week.
Wamp is a fan of contemporary Christian music and regularly watches the
drama series "Touched by an Angel," Kopper said.
"It points the American people in a positive, life-affirming direction,"
Kopper said of Wamp's choices.
Stupak's favorite movies, according to Bob Meisner, his press secretary,
are Kevin Costner's Civil War-era film epic "Dances With Wolves" and the
Roman battle film "Ben-Hur." Stupak, 47, listens to Bruce Springsteen
-- whose songs include "Nebraska," about a serial killer, and "Murder Inc."
Armey, 58, grew up watching and admiring film icon Wayne, who appeared
in the westerns "The Searchers," "Stagecoach" and "Big Jake," but also
in the Irish morality tale "The Quiet Man," said Jim Wilkinson, Armey's
spokesperson. Wilkinson said Armey concedes the violent content of Wayne's
most well-known work.
"People got shot in those movies," Wilkinson said. "But you never saw
the bullet holes. And the bad guys came back for the next movie.
"We just think this is a cultural argument," the spokesperson continued.
"Violence and the Marilyn Mansons have no place in the lives of children."
Cash, whom Wilkinson named along with Willie Nelson and Waylon Jennings
as artists Armey enjoys listening to, scored a major hit in 1956 with
"Folsom Prison Blues," in which a murderer confesses, "I shot a man in
Reno just to watch him die."
Hyde is a "huge" movie buff who sees at least two movies every weekend
and reports on his film-going experiences to his staff nearly every
Monday, said Michael Connolly, a spokesperson for the House Judiciary
Committee, which Hyde chairs. The 75-year-old congressman usually plays
classical music as he works in his office.
The primary opponents of Hyde's recently failed proposals, Reps. Mark
Foley, R-Fla., and James Rogan, R-Calif., diverge wildly in their
musical tastes.
The 44-year-old Rogan counts 1920s singer Al Jolson among his biggest
heroes, Jeffrey Solsby, Rogan's press secretary, said. While Jolson
didn't hint at violence in his music, he did wear blackface in the 1927
film "The Jazz Singer."
Meanwhile, Foley, 44, who feels the policing of media violence is better
left to the industries themselves, considered the Allman Brothers --
especially his friend, drummer Butch Trucks -- to be among his favorite
bands. Members of the band have struggled with drug addiction. "Midnight
Rider" and "Ramblin' Man" were among the hit songs they wrote and
recorded in their 1970s heyday.
Foley said the Allmans now present good role models for fans.
"With kids now, there's 2 percent bad apples, but 98 percent of them are
doing the right things," Foley said. "It's the same in the rock industry.
There's only a few people who act badly."