Glorious Crunchy Bubblegum Powerpop
Hi, my name is David, and I'm a power popper. Jonny Polonsky's a power
popper too. In fact, his debut, Hi My Name is Jonny, is such a
great unrepentant, unabated, unreconstructed power pop disc that it's
certain to be a dismal failure. But that just makes me love it all the
more.
Before we go on, I suppose I should be clear about exactly what I mean
by "power pop." I do not use that term in the hopelessly broad sense
that's recycled nowadays to describe everything from Def Leppard to
Nirvana. No, I mean power pop in its original, specific sense:
bubblegum melodies pumped up over big, crunchy-chorded electric guitar
rock that was frequently (but not always) decorated with
overwhelmingly tender touches, like lush, soaring strings and sweet
backing choirs. You know the stuff I mean, the sort of music that
filled out the pop charts throughout the 70s: Bad Finger's "Baby Blue,"
Sweet's "Little Willie," Rick Springfield's "Jesse's Girl," ELO's "Do
Ya," any number of singles from Queen, The Babys and Cheap Trick, and,
most archetypal of all, the Raspberries' simply glorious "Go All The
Way."
I know I'm not supposed to enjoy this stuff. Like most unabashedly pop-ular
music, power pop is no longer considered cool, at least not by the jaded
critics and Alternative Nation cynics whose opinions are supposed to matter
most. Partly this is because power pop sounds blatantly commercial. Which is
no surprise: after all, the genre was created--long, long ago in a land far,
far away--by artists who actually believed it was a good thing to have their
music heard by as many people as possible. (I mean, can you imagine
that?) Mainly, though, power pop's uncool today because it tends to be
filled with big, mushy emotional gestures (and over-the-top production and
arrangements such emotions often deserve) that are as earnest and sincere,
as romantic and idealistic and even naive, as most alterna-fans are winking
and ironic. I mean, even someone like the-not-afraid-to-be-campy Freddie
Mercury was, like, passionately serious when he sang that someone or other
was his best friend, or that we are the champions of the world, or that
"Momma, my life had just begin and now I've gone and blown it all away," no
matter how kitschy Wayne and Garth made it seem. Nowadays, everyone
knows
that passionate and serious are the most horribly embarrassing things you
could possibly be. (And, no, Oasis is not the exception that proves the
rule. The Gallaghers may have succeeded with the pop half of the power-pop
equation, but that's only because they are careful to never let us see them
sweat. They aren't serious; they're stoic.)
None of this means that power pop has completely disappeared. The overrated
Matthew Sweet is as close as the genre has to a grunged-up poster child
these days, and bands like Red Kross, Jellyfish, Material Issue and Urge
Overkill have also been known to combine their big guitars with sweet-tart
melodies. Still, it's not like any of these acts are wildly popular. Adam
Schmitt, the genre's best contemporary artisthis debut, World
So Bright, is as good a power-pop album as has ever been
maderemains all but unknown.
I hope Jonny Polonsky isn't about to suffer the same fate, but I'm pretty
certain he will. Sure, Polonsky has listened to more than his share of Eric
Carmen, Freddie Mercury and Paul McCartney (an important proto power
popper), and you can hear their influence all over Hi My Name Is
Jonny. "Evil Scurvy Love," for example, is a better mid-tempo Paul song
than Paul has written in a decade or more (It even includes a "Rocky
Raccoon" pianie solo.), and throughout the disc, Polonsky's singing, while
less polished than Carmen's and Mercury's, has the same kind of all-out
sincerity you can find in "All By Myself" or "Somebody To Love." What's
really going to do Polonsky in, though, is what I hear as his biggest
influence of all. Jonny Polonsky is a huge (gasp!) Jeff Lynne fan. In
alternative circles, someone as heavy-handed, 'mersh, and fancifully
romantic as Lynne is bound to be not only uncool but downright reviled, but
Polonsky wears the ELO influence on his sleeve, like a hardcore power-pop
badge of honor. In fact, most of Hi My Name Is Jonny plays as if a
long-lost Electric Light Orchestra album had suddenly materialized out of
the blue. And a damn good one.
I should be specific again about what I mean. I ain't talkin' about the
pretentious classical-rock crap of early ELO albums like No Answer
and ELO II. And I also don't mean late period ELO discs like
Time or (ugh) Secret Passages, where Lynne's magic for pop
hooks and production had twisted into a parody of what had been (admittedly)
a pretty formulaic sound all along. No, I mean ELO's mid-70s glory days,
especially the band's proud and (often) power-pop triumvirate, Face The
Music, A New World Record, and Out Of The Blue.
Granted, Polonsky is aware enough to lose Lynne's orchestra, echo and
mass choir, but don't let that fool you. The catchy as-all-get-out "In
My Mind" uses layered backing guitars to get the same string effect,
and both that song and "Half Mind" are driven by Lynne's patented
metronome-acoustic-guitar chug before they burst into cool,
synthy-sounding "Mr. Blue Sky" guitar solos. The lonely cry of "Gone
Away" is as radio ready, and just plain perfect, as an unplugged "Sweet
Talkin' Woman" for the 90s, and the sweetly innocent "It's Good To
Sleep" (because, Polonsky concludes, "Dreams help you be") is a
super-slow-mo power ballad, a la the patented ELO sounds of "Telephone
Line" or "Steppin' Out."
Like ELO's, Polonsky's lyrical point of view is simultaneously silly
and slight and serious as hell. "Uh Oh," the most ELO-sounding song on
the album, relates the post-death experiences of man felled by a bad
batch of souvlaki, while the remainder of the disc deals with lost love
in the poppiest, most clever terms possible. "Love Lovely Love," which
ought to go down as a big-guitar power-pop classic, has Polonsky
doubting how a woman as wonderful as his girlfriend could ever go for a
nerd like himat least he doubts it until he sees her again
and all he can shout then is: "I break out with copious tears/
Rejoicing at the joy in my life at the moment." And he's serious.
"Love Lovely Love" is as contemporary sounding as anything on the disc,
so it's easy to see why it's also the album's first single. With the
"power" cranked up just a bit, and the "pop" played down a tad, it
easily demonstrates how straight a line can be drawn from the very
uncool power pop tradition that Polonsky loves to the very cool sound
and vision of revered "punk rockers" like Dave Pirner, Paul
Westerberg, John Rzeznik, and even Frank Black (who reportedly
"discovered" Polonsky). But the rest of the disc doesn't worry about
making connections. It just cranks the power pop, sweet and loud and
unashamed. I'm not ashamed to admit I love it.