Soulful Queen Of Roses
"A rose is a rose is a rose," said eccentric writer and U.S.-turned-
Paris resident Gertrude Stein. "A rose is still a rose," said Queen of
Soul and suburban Detroit resident Aretha Franklin. For some
reason
-- I don't know, maybe it's the inimitable voice -- I'm more moved
by
Aretha's words, even if she didn't actually write them
(Lauryn
Hill of the Fugees, one of A Rose is Still a Rose's
producers,
did, but Aretha makes them her own).
Flowers aside, Franklin is in fine form on this, her first album of
new material since 1991.
As I sit gazing at the album cover photo of Aretha, whose long hair
cascades down her back, and listening to the hip-hop-influenced
single, "A Rose is Still a Rose," I
can't help but compare this song to "Respect," "(You Make Me Feel
Like) A Natural Woman" and "Chain of Fools." What I end up
concluding is that the anger and indignation of "Respect" or "Chain
of
Fools" would sound forced or
silly coming from this wise and mature woman, whose new album
is
more mellow than her old stuff but not without hints of regret and
pain.
Aretha offers empathy in "A Rose is Still a Rose" ("Listen dear, I
realize you've been hurt"), but she's not all cozy, maternal
warmth (thank goodness). There's also a slight edge to this song,
derived from ruthless truth-telling. But aside from all that
evocative stuff, this song road-tests well. In fact, when I was
driving through upstate New York and "A Rose is Still a Rose"
came
on the radio, I cranked it up and did the dancin'-in-my-car thing. I
was singing along, and people driving by were looking at me like I
was nuts. One of the best things about the song is the looped, not
really sampled, "What I am is what I am," from the Edie
Brickell and New Bohemians' hit ("What I Am").
While, of course, the Aretha of the 1960s will not return, and while
it would be flip to say that her present songwriters and producers
don't have the magic that, say, Jerry Wexler (one of her producers
from way back when) had, it's also true that Puffy Combs' song,
"Never Gonna Leave You Again," is so bland that I found
myself immediately thinking of other things -- housework, a
telephone call I had to make -- anything but the track blasting from
my stereo. In fact, it was all I could do not to turn it down and get
on with my business. Fake
phone-ringing (Maybe that's why I wanted to return phone calls?)
and
a busy, hip-hop recording grate annoyingly in this slowish love
song.
What was Combs thinking? I mean, kudos to Aretha for working
with
new, fashionable, successful musicians, but Puffy is a drag. (Still,
Puffy aside, most of the time Aretha's voice makes even the
mundane sound extraordinary.) Other songs include: "Here We Go
Again," which has a nice Sister Sledge vibe going on; "Every Li'l
Bit
Hurts," which reminds me of solid, radio-friendly Boyz II Men; and
"I'll Dip" (i.e., dip out), a song about leaving your man that wins the
most intriguing song title award.
While nothing here quite evokes the power or urgency of the
Aretha
of the late '60s, A Rose is Still a Rose proves that the
Queen
of Soul is still holding court.