Thursday night’s (October 20) premiere of The Rocky Horror Picture Show had us doing the Time Warp again. Victoria Justice stripped down to play heroine Janet Weiss in the reboot of the 1975 film, and her Victorious costar Avan Jogia was quick to congratulate her on her success.

He shared a fun throwback pic of the pair, along with Josh Hutcherson, from when the three apparently attended a live show of The Rocky Horror Picture Show together. Justice loved the trip down memory lane, and so did fans.

Jogia and Justice shippers (affectionately known as Vavan) started freaking out at the sweet exchange, commenting how their “heart hurts,” they were “shook,” and how Vavan is the “otp [and] everyone else is irrelevant.”

Some fans accompanied Jogia’s posts with even more pics from their old RHPS outings. I mean, you can never have too many throwback pics, can you?