I'm not sure how American audiences will take to the new docu-comedy series Creature Comforts, which launched last night on CBS.

Based on an Academy Award-winning film by Nick Park, creator of Wallace & Gromit, Creature Comforts is in fact a series of man-on-the-street interviews with members of the general populace. The audio tracks are then set to the humorous visual juxtaposition of claymation-based animals, ranging from dogs and cats to bees and giraffes. The UK version of the series aired on ITV and, as a huge Wallace & Gromit fan, I couldn't help but be enchanted with its home-spun wisdoms about the behaviors of (human) animals.

Everyone has a place within Creature Comforts, from old married couples to slacker dudes to little children, and each gets their chance to stand on the (animated) soapbox, talking about topics ranging from relationships and sex, to doctors, lying, and vacations. The premiere episode alone features a virtual menagerie of no less than horses, dogs, porcupines, hippopotami, giraffes, lions, slugs, and crayfish. The selection is meant to be slightly more US-centric, I believe, given the lack of "sheep, stoats, and rabbits."

Which brings us to the US version, which attempts to be just as winsomely charming as the original UK Creature Comforts, though I do feel as though there was something slightly just... missing. Maybe it was the far-too-familiar accents or the pedestrian vocal sounds of the slacker/stoner dog (talking about getting hit in the head with frisbees), but I sort of, you know, missed those varying English accents.

The concept of transforming raw, unscripted interviews on mundane topics into comedy is an interesting one. The trick, of course, is those Aardman-animated claymation animals. Watching a woman talk about how annoying it is to get weighed at the doctor's office would be cloying at best; watching a hippo talk about the indignity of being forced to weigh in by an Ally McBeal-thin nurse is hysterical. It's those very juxtapositions--a porcupine acknowledges that she's definitely not afraid of needles--that provide a glint of comedic gold.

However, all that glitters, as they say. Unfortunately, in watching Creature Comforts, I couldn't help but be struck how much better this snippets of conversation worked in Park's original short film rather than in a weekly half-hour series. A little bit goes a long way and, after a while, these conversations/sketches tend to drag on, especially without the help of the UK version's snappy score and some truly memorable "characters." (I'm thinking specifically of that married couple, portrayed by a saucy dog and cat in the UK Comforts.)

Here, however, the interviewees simply blend into one another, even with the adorable claymation animals serving to remind us that we are, at heart, animals one and all. In the final analysis, Creature Comforts is worth a peek for the curious, but I'd be hard-pressed to see this catching on with the public on an ongoing basis.

Creature Comforts airs Monday nights at 8 pm on CBS.

* * *

Jace is an LA-based television development and acquisitions junior exec who watches way too much television for his own good and would love a TiVo for every room in the house. (He’s halfway there.) His blog, Televisionary, can be found at televisionaryblog.com.