We're midway through The Island and I've lost count of how many times Johnny's called someone a "dumb bitch." But who was the dumb bitch tonight, Bananas?! Only time will tell whether Evelyn's ballsy move stealing Johnny's key was smart -- but one thing's for certain, she sure caused a ruckus amongst the ranks. In fact, Paula's still not over it.

Watch the clip below to hear Paula's vengeful plot and find out who was nominated Biggest Badass of The Island.