Eleven years ago, the Halloween episode of Zoey 101 turned the classic haunted house story upside down when Zoey (Jamie Lynn Spears), Dustin (Paul Butcher), and the rest of the gang decided to epically scare Logan (Matthew Underwood) in his own haunted house.

On Monday (October 31), series creator Dan Schneider shared a fun behind-the-scenes throwback video about the episode. Several of the cast was interviewed — except for Christopher Massey (who played Michael), since he hilariously blanked when asked what the episode was about. Moreover, Underwood perfectly summed up Logan's reaction to getting scared: “I turn into a little baby.” Check out the nostalgia-inducing video below.