Hop into a time machine and travel back to 1999, because the stars of She’s All That just reunited 17 years later. On Thursday, ’90s heartthrob Freddie Prinze Jr. tweeted a photo with Rachael Leigh Cook. The old friends got together for a cup of coffee!

A brownie may or not have been involved as well.

In case you need a refresher, She’s All That told the classic tale of a popular guy (Prinze) who bets he can turn his artsy, shy classmate (Cook) into their high school’s prom queen. After a makeover that mostly involved trimming her hair and taking off her glasses, Cook’s character emerged looking like the goddess she always was — whether she’s wearing paint-spattered overalls or a flirty red cocktail dress.

Of course, girls don’t particularly enjoy being betted on, so that creates hell for Prinze’s character. It’s great to see that they’re still friends after all these years, though!