Pia Toscano is sent packing on Rock and Roll Week, which causes Jim Cantiello to rant about the judges.
Jim..You are Brilliant! The Judges are USELESS and so annoying it's hard to watch! "Oh Baby baby baby your sooooo perfect" ~ "Dude, Dude. dude, your in it to win it" ~ "That was beautifuf Man, just beautiful"!! STFU and tell the truth!! OMG! I want Simon back sooo bad! Adam tweeted.."I wonder what Simon would have to say to these contestants"? LOL!
Now that would be "Beautiful"
The show is a JOKE now...they are trying everything to save it and it is backfireing fast! So sad..JUDGES,,listen up! But you can clearly see JLO is way tooooo ass stubburn to humble herself and change her ********! I hope Simons new show put Idols Lights out for good.
Jim you should be a judge..
*** are you staring at her crotch for anyways??I thought all of her was so fine!!
Jim, you have NEVER been more on point. I love, love Steven but this year all 3 judges have been totally useless in their comments. They don't have to be mean,but the kids are getting no truth, nothing to help them, just fawning and drivel. Simon would sometimes bring me flying out of my chair with a nasty criticism, but so often he was right.
People want a SHOW, they want excitement along with the talent, at least a little, and they want to glimpse some personality, and you are right, they don't seem to want, for very long, a female. I pretty much gave up on Idol after the travesty that was Adam not winning (of course, we know that it didn't matter, but still) and then last year's disaster of boredom, but to coddle these people makes no sense. Why didn't they tell James he was flat on sooooo many notes, tell Pia and Stefano to interact emotionally if not physically with the audience, etc.
"You get back what you give away," so if they would give away a little truth, they would get back some improved performances and perhaps more valid voting results.
Thank you, Jim, for pointing out that it wasn't all about the vag, that Pia really needs some work to be successful. And for the boom-fiyah judges critique - as you said, it's not that they need to tell America who to vote for, it's that they need to tell the contestants what to do to make themselves viable artists!
Absolutely brilliant, Jim, thank you. I hope someone at Idol is watching this!
Thanks for putting the blame where it belongs on the judges not the voters.
Great recap Jim and bonus points for the Michael Kors' clip. The judges need to judge and earn their checks.