"Idol" expert Jim Cantiello recaps all the Rolling Stones performances from Tuesday night. (3.16.10)
Why does Tim Urban keep coming back? He might be cute but I don't think he can sing, not at all. He sang the worst on Tuesday, and Lacey did way better. I wish Alex Lambert and Katelyn Epperly hadn't left. Both are way more talented than Tim Urban =P my opinion! Just saying.
I never realized just how creepy the lyrics are to "Under My Thumb" until I heard Tim Urban sing it in that laid back reggae style with that genial smile. It could have been in the soundtrack of a serial killer movie.
Not perfect, but I loved Siohban. Especially that beautiful ending after the wail. I rewatched the ending two more times, and teared everytime I heard it. This week I'm Team Siohban! Still like Crystal though.
I wish Andrew Garcia and Tim Urban could switch bodies/heads. Things would work out a little more appropiately. Is that terrible to say? Siobhan gave me chills. Didi made me want more. Lacey and her string quartet made my heart happy. Andrew finally sounded good again (in my opinion). The rest were just a'ight for me, man.
not getting Magnus much, she has been kind of boring. Crystal, she is really good... just not my thing.
I was a little confused reconciling weepy Crystal dad w/her beautifully chilling song Farmer's Daughter, but with the absence of mom, I'm seeing it in a whole new light. Yikes. Girl is a survivor and belongs center stage. Yeah, Aaron's Angie gave me the creeps, tho vocally not bad, sometimes you are just too young to sing a song.
I'm so glad you commented on the waltz-y time signature at the beginning of Paint it Black! That was my favorite part of the song, and anyone who can change the time signature of a song is an A+ in my book. Four for you, Siobhan!
siobhan and crystal are the only ones worth watching, let's be honest. everyone else = fail whale. casey's ok to watch with the volume muted, mmm
Truthfully I think Tim Urban has a good voice. Or maybe I'm disillusioned because there are so many mediocre contestants this season. Despite her Gokey note, I still love Siobhan. Crystal was a little too low energy this week, but she's still #2 on my list. This was the first week I liked Didi although I wouldn't vote for her. Casey still has something I like (not exactly sure what, although I do love how he smiles while he sings) and I still like Lee's voice a lot. I'd like to see Lacey stay another week. Other than that, I don't care.
Whether Simon hated it or not I really liked Tim Urban(: I voted for him One after the other from 9-10 xD (I swear I'm not obsessed lol)