Sucks to be you, girl.
"We looked over everything. First things first, we wanted to check out his Facebook page," Nev says, explaining that he and Max wanted to see if the catfish had been having "conversations" with anyone else.
And lo and behold, he was -- including one with a girl named Zoey. And when Nev and Max reached out to Miss Z, she replied with some 411 that rocks April's world.
What did Zoey say? Watch the clip to find out, and to see April's story unfold, catch Catfish Wednesday at 10/9c.