DVD Review: Hunger - Criterion Collection

Hoorah for Criterion, for taking on this extraordinary film and giving it to us in a spectacular home version.

Pretty? Heh -- no. This is not a pretty film. It's a hard, harsh film -- powerfully cinematic, it veers from nearly wordless stretches of intense imagery so vivid they're surrealistic nightmares come to life to one 20-minute, unbroken dialogue between two men on opposite sides of the same side, an impassioned debate that underlies why one of them is enduring the nightmare we're enduring alongside him.

It's like some third-world prison, the block where members of the IRA are being held in 1981 by the occupying British forces in Northern Ireland. The Brits refuse to acknowledge that men like Bobby Sands are political prisoners, and so the prisoners fight back, which first-time director Steve McQueen, in the Criterion interview, calls "the most important event in British history in recent times." As Hunger opens, they are in the middle of a protest that sees them wearing only blankets -- they refuse to wear prison garb, demanding their own clothes instead -- and not washing. The horrible wonderfulness of how McQueen depicts the conditions here mires you in it: close-ups on faces or hands or feces-stained walls -- that's another prisoner protest -- so concentrated they become almost abstract; moody shadows in which lurk unspoken determination ... on the parts of both prisoners and guards. McQueen, who wrote the script with Enda Walsh, doesn't ignore the strange plight of the guards: one scene sees a terrible beating of several prisoners by riot-gear-clad stormtroopers who revel in their own viciousness, but much, much harder to take is the one young trooper hiding around the corner, sobbing, unwilling to participate in an atrocity that will surely change him forever anyway, for good or ill.

Soon, though, almost without you realizing he's done it, McQueen -- who was a painter and maker of non-narrative museum-piece art films before he made this, his feature debut -- zeroes in on a scarily resolute Michael Fassbender (Inglourious Basterds) as Sands. And by the time he has his 20-minute conversation with a priest (Liam Cunningham) explaining why he and his fellow prisoners have to up the ante with a hunger strike calculated to break the political will of the British, you're with him. In the cold light of day, once you've put the DVD away and you're no longer in that awful prison with Sands, it may not seem as reasonable and rational -- or, indeed, it may -- but McQueen has created such a potent argument, in the simplest, most visual terms, that you don't merely understand on an intellectual level but feel on a visceral level that sometimes going to the most extreme of extremes is the only way one has left to exert oneself.

This Criterion edition features a vibrant new high-def transfer at the film's original 2.35:1 aspect ratio. Also included on the disc is a making-of documentary and a 1981 BBC news program, "The Provos' Last Card?" produced four months after Sands' death.

Hunger is available now from the Criterion Collection.


MaryAnn Johanson enjoys eating too much to ever hunger strike at FlickFilosopher.com. (email me)

Movie & TV Awards 2018