Rihanna in September 2009, Madonna in November 2010, and Blake Lively in January 2010.

Photo: Getty Images/Splash

Stella McCartney's perforated thigh-high boots were one of the most popular boot styles when they launched for fall 2009, and just because they're from last season doesn't mean they're over. Just last week Madonna stepped out wearing these boots, which retailed for $1,595 before they sold out. She pairing them with a sparkly tunic by Roberto Cavalli. Other starlets also fell for these boots: Rihanna wore them with a gray jersey dress, and Gossip Girl's Blake Lively wore them with a white men's shirt and black boyfriend blazer. Overall, we think Madonna looks best in these boots because she didn't dress them down by pairing them with casual clothes. Rather, she embraced the wild look with something equally attention-getting up top. But what do you think?

+ Who wore these Stella McCartney boots best -- Rihanna, Madonna, or Blake?