Sneak Peek: Tyler And Johnny Go At It During The 'Cutthroat' Reunion

When Johnny Bananas got sent on his merry way during last night's episode of "Cutthroat," we were completely shocked (even though watching CT turn the loudmouth into a limp noodle was pretty awesome). Do you wonder what would've happened if JB faced Tyler in the Gulag like he was supposed to...because the rest of the cast sure does.

Check out the "Challenge: Cutthroat Reunion Special" sneak peek below (airs next Wednesday at 11/10c), where the battle of the bros continues. Tyler refuses to admit (or even consider) that the results could've been different had he been strapped to Johnny. We smell a rematch.