VIDEO: Johnny Calls Casey The 'Best Player' He's Got!

Brad came down pretty hard on Casey this week, but he's not the only one who thinks she's single-handedly sabotaging his team. According to Evan, Casey was like a dream wrapped in a miracle, and Johnny Bananas (who compared her to the best closer in baseball) seems to think she's a shoo-in for Ruins MVP.

Hear the Champs explain why they couldn't have dug Casey more if she was their own flesh-and-blood love child, then check out (an understandably still-frustrated) Sarah try and describe what it was like watching Smokey McGee giggle her way to last place every single week.

+ Want more Ruins Replay? Find out whether Cohutta and Susie's first kiss was also their last, plus hear Sarah 'fess up to having a MAJOR crush on Kenny.