YOUR FAVORITE MTV SHOWS ARE ON PARAMOUNT+

Who Is Devin's 'Are You The One?' Perfect Match: Kiki Or Melanie?

The New Englander was a hit with the ladies on tonight's premiere.

A guy or gal juggling two admirers is par for the course on "Are You the One?" -- and Devin found himself in this romantic scenario right out of the gate. But who is the New Englander's perfect match: Kiki or Melanie?

During tonight's premiere episode, both ladies quickly set their sights on the 26-year-old -- and for a man who declared the way he has game is by "not having any game at all," he certainly got a whole lot of attention in paradise. The first to strike was Kiki: After the duo discovered their mutual admiration for meditation, they quickly engaged in a bit of morning exercise on the front lawn.

8

"He led a yoga class for me," K gushed during a confessional interview, while D stroked her hair. "It was legit," she stated, while he declared that his gal pal is "beautiful" and "smart." The couple that knows how to strike a pose together clearrrrrrrly stays together.

But Kiki's happy state was short-lived: During the first getaway challenge, Melanie was one of the top four finishers -- and she picked Big D as her companion.

"I like guys who make me laugh," the New Yorker admitted while sharing an embrace with her date.

But perhaps even more awkward? Hunter, another winner, picked Kiki. While K tried to have a good attitude about the sweet Southerner's kind gesture, her heart belonged elsewhere. And her gut about H was spot-on: The two were the first to be voted into the Truth Booth and found they are not scientifically compatible.

But back to Devin: His conversation with Mel during the Hawaii excursion quickly turned awkward when he revealed he had cheated on all of his past girlfriends. And even though she called him out for his previous indiscretions, M later snagged D at the first Match-Up ceremony before K could get a chance.

HDRUO301ASNEAK2_1.mp4.01_00_18_14.Still004_promo_edited

But things at the formal evening went from jokey to just plain uncomfortable: After D called both K and M "wonderful" and "gorgeous," Nelson claimed that Devin revealed he wanted to"smash both of them." While Kiki was off on the side crying, Mel exclaimed she wanted to change her choice. And this is only week one, folks!

The gang only got two beams of light, so is one of them for Delanie? Even though the dancer felt some sparks initially toward the pot-stirrer, she clearly had a tough time stomaching D's inability to be faithful to his erstwhile partners and his current player-like tendencies. The other woman in this equation, Kiki, obviously fell hard for Devin and their bond grew because of their shared interests. N's statement caused her to feel a great sense of betrayal and she felt understandably rattled.

So who is Devin's perfect match? Is it Melanie? Could it be Kiki? Or is it another gal? Share your theories in the comments, and be sure to catch "Are You the One" during its new regular time on Wednesdays at 10/9c! And for an added bonus, watch K dish why she was initially attracted to D in the clip below:

Latest News