Getty

Lady Gaga And Taylor Kinney Surprise Small Church: Here's Why

Are you thinking what I'm thinking?

So, Lady Gaga and Taylor Kinney showed up at a small Pennsylvanian church last Sunday, which could only mean one thing, right? They were attending a family baptism!

I know, I know, I was hoping for a Gaga wedding too.

According to LancasterOnline and the ever-reliable Twitter, Gaga and "Chicago Fire" boyfriend Kinney showed up at the Grandview United Methodist Church that his aunt frequents. Kinney graduated from Lancaster Mennonite High School in 2000.

People were stunned about the couple being there:

But no one was more excited than 24-year-old Liz Fulmer, who performed a song that day and told LancasterOnline, “People from the church told me that she whispered to her boyfriend that I was good.”

She even says she got a text from the singer, saying: "“Hi Liz, it’s Gaga ... You were sensational. Keep up the amazing work.”