YOUR FAVORITE MTV SHOWS ARE ON PARAMOUNT+

'Faking It' Poll: Now That Amy And Liam Did The Deed, Who Should Come Clean To Karma?

We have a very messy situation on our hands -- so who should spill the beans?

In case you've forgotten -- but really, how could you? -- the last few seconds of "Faking It"'s Season 1 featured a very unlikely (and inebriated) duo of Liam and Amy hitting the sheets after a whirlwind evening in which hearts were broken and lies were exposed. And as we saw in the trailer for Season 2 -- which premieres on Tuesday, September 23 at 10:30/9:30c -- the pair wake up in bed together and can't help but wonder what the hell happened.

Related: Getting Karmotional: How Will Karma Cope With The 'Faking It' Bomb Drop?

But let's rewind: The unexpected romp occurred after Amy professed her love for her best friend and faux girlfriend Karma, only to learn shortly afterward that not only did her bestie not feel the same way, but she had also sealed the deal with the hunky artist. Earlier, L felt cheated when he learned the truth about Karmy's made-up lesbian affair. So the equally deceived combo of Amy and Liam pounded the bottle -- and eventually found themselves with their clothes off and in the sack.

Amy and Liam are harboring a big secret -- and it's unclear how long they'll keep it to themselves -- but when the truth eventually comes out and they admit their indiscretions, who should come clean to the sprightly Hester High student? Is it up to Amy to tell her dear pal that she hooked up with her crush, or should Karma's former love interest spill the beans? Or should they sit the aspiring singer down together and make it a joint effort? Take our poll, let us know your thoughts in the comments and be sure to catch the season premiere on Tuesday at 10:30/9:30c!

[funnel_poll id="fakingit_jordana_9_17_14" results="true"]

Latest News