When it comes to the first-ever mtvU Fandom Awards -- which crowns the most dedicated fanbase of the year -- every vote counts.
But some votes count more than others. Namely, that of MTV News' Josh Horowitz.
Kat Graham made her pitch for "The Vampire Diaries" through a pop-up window on Josh’s computer screen, before Manganiello dropped by his cubicle for a face-to-face.
The “True Blood" actor deemed "Orphan Black" the "best show ever" with the help of two clones, while Amber was there to make the case for “Frozen." Oh, and Nick Cannon naturally stops by to tout "Pretty Little Liars," saying, "I am a Pretty Little Liar."