Pia Toscano's Early Exit Shakes Up 'American Idol' Odds

Bodog now has Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina as the favorites to win season 10.

Pia Toscano's early exit from "American Idol" has shocked experts, celebs and fans. And, as it turns out, it was also a shock to a group of folks who don't get shocked all that often: oddsmakers.

It seems that, in the wake of Toscano's elimination, the brain trust at Bodog's sportsbook has been forced to rejigger their odds. For weeks, they slowly moved her up the list of likely "Idol" winners — she originally opened as a 14/1 long shot, but heading into Wednesday night's show, she was a 2/1 favorite to take home the crown — and now that she's out, they've anointed Scotty McCreery and Lauren Alaina as the new co-favorites.

Bodog gives both singers 5/2 odds at winning "Idol," followed by James Durbin at 4/1. Haley Reinhart gets 15/2 odds, Casey Abrams gets 8/1 and Paul McDonald is in at 12/1. Jacob Lusk and Stefano Langone bring up the rear, getting 14/1 and 20/1 odds, respectively.

And though they were forced to re-shuffle, the folks at Bodog have let the initial shock of Toscano's departure wear off. Because, as they put it, no matter how hard anyone tries, it's often impossible to make sense of the whims of "Idol" voters.

"From the beginning of the season, Pia Toscano had been a popular bet who ... was a clear favorite to win it all," Bodog sportsbook manager Richard Gardner said. "It may be a shock that she was sent home, but with all the contestants putting on a solid performance the other night and the track record that this show has for voting the wrong people through, I am not surprised at all."

Get your "Idol" fix on MTV News' "American Idol" page, where you'll find all the latest news, interviews and opinions.