| Category | Recipient | Award |
|---|---|---|
| Outstanding Lead Actor In A Miniseries Or A Movie (Nomination) |
Recount (2008) |
Emmy |
| Best Actor - Comedy or Musical (Nomination) |
Beyond the Sea (2004) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Actor - Drama (Nomination) |
Shipping News (2001) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Actor (Nomination) |
Shipping News (2001) |
British Academy Awards |
| Best Actor (Winner) |
American Beauty (1999) |
Academy |
| Best Actor - Drama (Nomination) |
American Beauty (1999) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Actor (Winner) |
American Beauty (1999) |
British Academy Awards |
| Best Actor (Winner) |
American Beauty (1999) |
Chicago Film Critics Association |
| Best Actor (Winner) |
American Beauty (1999) |
Toronto Film Critics Association |
| Best Male Actor in a Leading Role (Winner) |
American Beauty (1999) |
Screen Actors Guild |
| Best Supporting Actor (Winner) |
Seven (1995) |
National Board of Review |
| Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) (Winner) |
Seven (1995) |
National Society of Film Critics |
| Best Supporting Actor (Winner) |
Outbreak (1995) |
New York Film Critics Circle |
| Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) (Winner) |
Outbreak (1995) |
National Society of Film Critics |
| Best Actor (Nomination) |
Swimming with Sharks (1995) |
Independent Spirit Award |
| Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) (Winner) |
Swimming with Sharks (1995) |
National Society of Film Critics |
| Best Supporting Actor (Winner) |
Usual Suspects (1995) |
Academy |
| Best Supporting Actor (Nomination) |
Usual Suspects (1995) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Supporting Actor (Nomination) |
Usual Suspects (1995) |
Screen Actors Guild |
| Best Supporting Actor (Winner) |
Usual Suspects (1995) |
National Board of Review |
| Best Supporting Actor (Winner) |
Usual Suspects (1995) |
Chicago Film Critics Association |
| Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) (Winner) |
Usual Suspects (1995) |
National Society of Film Critics |
