| Category | Recipient | Award |
|---|---|---|
| Best Actor (Nomination) |
Into the Wild (2007) |
Screen Actors Guild |
| Best Actor (Nomination) |
Into the Wild (2007) |
Detroit Film Critics Society |
| Best Actor (Nomination) |
Into the Wild (2007) |
Broadcast Film Critics Association |
| Best Breakthrough Performance by an Actor (Winner) |
Into the Wild (2007) |
National Board of Review |