| Year | Movie | Award | Category | |||
| 2006 | The Painted Veil | Independent Spirit Awards | Best Actor | |||
| 1998 | American History X | Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Scie | Best Actor | |||
| 1996 | Everyone Says I Love You | National Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) | |||
| 1996 | Primal Fear | National Board of Review | Best Supporting Actor | |||
| 1996 | Everyone Says I Love You | National Board of Review | Best Supporting Actor | |||
| 1996 | The People Vs. Larry Flynt | Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | |||
| 1996 | Primal Fear | Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | |||
| 1996 | Everyone Says I Love You | Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Supporting Actor | |||
| 1996 | Primal Fear | Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Scie | Best Supporting Actor | |||
| 1996 | Primal Fear | Hollywood Foreign Press Association | Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Pic | |||
| 1996 | The People Vs. Larry Flynt | Chicago Film Critics Association | Most Promising Actor | |||
| 1996 | Primal Fear | Chicago Film Critics Association | Most Promising Actor | |||
| 1996 | Everyone Says I Love You | Chicago Film Critics Association | Most Promising Actor | |||
| 1996 | The People Vs. Larry Flynt | National Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) | |||
| 1996 | Primal Fear | National Society of Film Critics | Best Supporting Actor (Runner-up) | |||
| 1996 | The People Vs. Larry Flynt | National Board of Review | Best Supporting Actor |