Robert De Niro (Lorenzo Anello)
Chazz Palminteri (Sonny)
Lillo Brancato Jr. (Calogero Anello (Age 17))
Francis Capra (Calogero Anello (Age 9))
Taral Hicks (Jane)
Patrick Borriello (Slick (Age 9))
Joe Black (Murdered Man)
Chad Dowdell (Joey's Friend (uncredited))
Domenick Lombardozzi (Nicky Zero)
Elizabeth Abassi (Lady in Window)
Mitch Kolpan (Detective Belsik)
Ellen Chenoweth
Ida Bemardini (Fish Store Customer)
Garry Blackwood (Chez Bippy Customer)
Nicky Blair (Jerry)
Joseph D'Onofrio (Slick age 17)
Dave Salerno (Frankie Coffecake)
Tommy A. Ford (Phil the Peddler)
Steve Pendleton (Satan's Messenger)
Paul Perri (Crazy Mario (Age 9))
Joe Pesci (Carmine)
Kathrine Narducci (Rosina Anello)
Clem Caserta (Jimmy Whispers)
Alfred Sauchelli, Jr. (Bobby Bars)