Claudette Colbert (Lydia Kenyon)
Ray Milland (Tony Kenyon)
Brian Aherne (Jim Blake)
Binnie Barnes (Myrtle Vantine)
Walter Abel (George Gore)
Minerva Urecal (Woman in subway car)
Howard Mitchell (Man in front of Tony)
Virginia Sale (Woman in subway car)
Ella Neal (Usherette)
William Newell (Counterman)
Frank Orth (Subway cashier)
Edward Peil Sr. (Man behind Tony)
Armand Kaliz (Jeweler)
Francisco Maran (Mr. Harrison)
Maggie Hayes (Receptionist)
James Flavin (Subway guard)
Keith Richards (Counterman, 2nd hamburger stand)
Fritz Feld (Maitre d'Hotel)
Patricia Farr (Waitress)
Robert Dudley (Pedestrian)
May Boley (Fat woman in subway car)
Henry Roquemore (Bartender)
Leonard Mudie (Jewelry clerk)
Warren Hymer (Big man in subway car)
Hobart Cavanaugh (Small man in subway car)
Edward Fielding (Scholarly man in subway car)
Leon Belasco (Man with long hair)
Irving Bacon (Ferryman)
Grant Mitchell (Frederick Vantine)
Mona Barrie (Charlotte Gorell)
Ernest Cossart (Theodore)
James Rennie (Ned Franklin)