| Category | Recipient | Award |
|---|---|---|
| Best Editing (Winner) |
Robert Rodriguez (2005) |
Online Film Critics Association |
| Best Editing (Winner) |
Robert Rodriguez (2005) |
Phoenix Film Critics Association |
| Best Cinematography (Winner) |
Robert Rodriguez (2005) |
Online Film Critics Association |
| Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Pic (Winner) |
Mickey Rourke (2005) |
Online Film Critics Association |
| Best Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Role in a Motion Pic (Winner) |
Mickey Rourke (2005) |
Chicago Film Critics Association |
| In Competition (Nomination) |
Sin City (2005) |
Cannes Film Festival |
| Best Makeup (Winner) |
Sin City (2005) |
Phoenix Film Critics Association |
| Best Ensemble Acting (Nomination) |
Sin City (2005) |
Broadcast Film Critics Association |
| Top Ten Film of the Year (Winner) |
Sin City (2005) |
Phoenix Film Critics Association |
| Best Overlooked, Original, Innovative or Creative Film (Winner) |
Sin City (2005) |
St. Louis Gateway Film Critics Associat |
