| Category | Recipient | Award |
|---|---|---|
| Best Art Direction (Nomination) |
Celia Bobak (2004) |
Academy |
| Best Song (Nomination) |
Charles Hart (2004) |
Academy |
| Best Original Song (Nomination) |
Charles Hart (2004) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Actress - Comedy or Musical (Nomination) |
Emmy Rossum (2004) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Young Actress (Winner) |
Emmy Rossum (2004) |
Broadcast Film Critics Association |
| Breakthrough Performance - Female (Winner) |
Emmy Rossum (2004) |
National Board of Review |
| Best Cinematography (Nomination) |
John Mathieson (2004) |
Academy |
| Best Song (Nomination) |
Andrew Lloyd Webber (2004) |
Academy |
| Best Original Song (Nomination) |
Andrew Lloyd Webber (2004) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Art Direction (Nomination) |
Anthony Pratt (2004) |
Academy |
| Best Picture - Comedy or Musical (Nomination) |
Phantom of the Opera (2004) |
Golden Globe |
| Best Picture (Nomination) |
Phantom of the Opera (2004) |
Broadcast Film Critics Association |
